To: Hong Kong government 香港政府

Oppose Hong Kong Lantau Tomorrow Vision 反對香港明日大嶼

Oppose Hong Kong Lantau Tomorrow Vision 反對香港明日大嶼

As a part of the Hong Kong community, we call you, The Hong Kong Legislative Council, to take action and defend our home for the citizens, for the environment, and for the future, by refusing to let the Hong Kong Government force the Lantau Tomorrow Vision (LTV) Feasibility Study through the legislature. The HK Government plans to “solve the housing crisis” by spending ~HK$600 Billion to build a 1,700 hectares island in the middle of the ocean, that’s almost double the size of the Vatican City (1,000 hectares). However, the plan fails to enclose the financial drain, environmental damage, and failure to accomplish the intended goal.

香港立法會作為香港的一個立法機制,要捍衛我們香港人的家,保護香港的環境和香港的將來,是不可以讓“明日大嶼”(LTV)通過立法。香港政府利用解決房屋短缺這個的藉口,動用港幣6千億在海中填海造地1700公頃。差不多等於梵蒂岡的一倍。但是,政府仍然未有方案解決財政壓力,環境破壞,甚至填海是否真的可以解決香港居住問題。

Why is this important?

1. Outdated:
- The vision suggests that economic growth will be created by its implementation while providing minimal short-term, unsustainable economic growth in Hong Kong.
- In school, we’re taught the importance of sustainable, green development Hong Kong needs to explore a sustainable future where economic growth happens as a part of sustainable development as we are taught within our education.
- Reclamation is no longer a viable solution! It requires a large amount of sand for it to happen. However, as the world has begun running out of sand, sand prices have doubled since the Airport Expansion began, pushing its completion date back further and further. The LTV would need even more sand, so it’s price tag will either increase or it will be stopped halfway through.

2. Destructive to HK’s fragile environment:
- Hong Kong has one of the most biodiverse aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems. There are overall 1000 marine fish species and 80 hard coral species. This is more than the Caribbean Sea. However, infrastructure projects (mainly the HKIA Expansion and the Hong Kong-Zhuhai-Macau Bridge) have caused many species to die. Building the LTV will be the final nail in the coffin.
- Important endangered animals are residing within the area in which the LTV envisions developed. So far, the population of Chinese White Dolphins in HK waters fell from 188 to 32 between 2003 to 2018, 33 Finless Porpoises were found dead in 2018, making up 12% of the total population. If the LTV happens, they will go extinct.

3. Too expensive:
- It would be one of the biggest economical gambles ever made in the world. More realistic plans and policies should be taken to make progressive development such as enacting the "Land Resumption Ordinance" to take back 859 hectares from 3 developers while compensating them fairly, or even redeveloping old and underused buildings.

We, the undersigned, condemn the motion for the LTV's destructive nature on the environment during and after its development.

What we need is a sustainable land solution that will last for generations to come. We, the people, demand that the LTV not be passed and realized for sake of Hong Kong, and future generations.

1. 過時
- 預測 LTV 會帶來香港經濟增長。可惜,它只是一種短暫而不能持久的增長。
- 簡單而言,計劃是行不通的。在學校裡,我們學到的是香港持久綠色發展的重要性,如何從中發掘商業機會來促進經濟發展。
- 填海已經不是一個有效可行的方法。在填海過程中需要大量的沙。而沙在世界供應開始短缺,其價錢已升至機場擴建時的一倍。此外,隨著預計完工日期的延誤,沙的價格會隨之而上升。工程甚至會因沙短缺而被迫停止。

2. 破壞香港脆弱的生態環境
- 香港的海岸是世界出名的生物多樣性海洋生態,有超過1000種魚類和80種珊瑚,種類超越加勒比海。可是,多年來的基建已經引致很多海洋物種死亡。LTV 的興建會是宣佈牠們死亡的最後一句。
- 在興建 LTV 的範圍裡,生活了很多臨危物種,例如中華白海豚和江豚。其中中華白海豚的數目由2003年的188條下降至2018年的32條。相信興建 LTV 之後,牠們將會絕種了。

3. 太昂貴
這是世界上最大的經濟投資賭博。我們應該回歸現實。例如加強執行土地收回條例從3個發展商收回859公頃土地,或是重新發展舊樓和棄置未有用途樓宇。

我們重申,堅決反對LTV 破壞環境的建設。它只會用去我們最少60%香港儲備,但解決不了眼前嚴重土地短缺的問題。

我們需要的是一些可以與環境生態並存的可持續發展的土地方案。

Hong Kong

Maps © Stamen; Data © OSM and contributors, ODbL